Untitled Document
Union struggle is about the top issues for most Americans: health insurance
and a secure future
Back in December, when those 34,000 pesky bus and subway workers who belong
to Transport Workers Union Local 100 in New York City walked off the job, the
news media and local government traffic managers from Riverhead to Richmond
Hill did their level best to help minimize the hassle.
Another illegal strike is unlikely this year - although the union and the Metropolitan
Transportation Authority are having trouble getting together on an agreement
- but if it comes to that, we'll all be given plenty of notice about how our
commute will be affected.
I like people doing their jobs. In December, it was the news media keeping
us informed with newspaper headlines and top-of-the-hour stories on the radio
and the Web as the traffic impresarios struggled to keep the cars dancing on
the Long Island Expressway from stepping on each others' toes.
But I've been thinking, too, about the job the union of transit workers has
been doing. Not the good work the members of the union as MTA employees do each
day, safely moving millions to work and school and home again on the country's
largest public transport system. I'm talking about the job of being a union.
Although Local 100 has its problems - it rejected the MTA's contract offer in
January by only seven votes and remains troubled by factionalism - I see the
transit workers carrying out the historic mission of a labor union. Looking
closer, I see them acting as a countervailing power in the struggle for economic
and social justice - not just to protect the interests of their dues-paying
members but to sound the alarm that the general interest of the vast majority
of all New Yorkers, and the vast majority of Americans, is at stake.
The health insurance you and I count on to protect our family is at risk as
never before. Costs are skyrocketing and working families, businesses and local
governments are feeling the pinch. Fewer employers are offering health insurance.
About one-third of personal bankruptcy, now at record levels, results from medical
bills that can't be paid, even for people with health insurance. And never before
have pension plans in the private sector been in such dire shape. Businesses
are switching to 401(k) plans to shed costs - and a social responsibility they
traditionally shouldered. The result is less security for average workers.
Although the public-sector retirement system in New York remains relatively
stable, it will not remain immune from attack by those who want to expand a
"you own your own" health and retirement system - a system designed
to fatten the coffers of insurance companies, investors and banks.
The struggle of the transit workers is really about the most important domestic
issue facing American society: how to maintain jobs that provide a wage to live
on and raise a family, and how to provide a decent and secure health insurance
and retirement plan. Why would nearly 34,000 workers conduct an illegal strike
knowing full well the severe legal and financial penalties that can be imposed
on each worker?
There are a number of ways to answer this question. In Harlem, there's a 50
percent unemployment rate among black males. A large number of transit workers
are black men, and they know, as most transit workers do, that their union is
all that stands between them and sinking to the poverty level. According to
the Bureau of Labor Statistics, union members have about a 30 percent wage advantage
over nonunion workers. Transit workers generally, whatever their gender or skin
color, live paycheck to paycheck. They're not rich, but they know their union
job is the best anti-poverty plan.
In America, there seems to be an ethos that any exercise of working-class power
is a corruption of the natural order, as if fighting to protect social values
such as fairness, equality, safety and security is less important than the dog-eat-dog
values of the marketplace. Transit workers have taken significant risks because
they do not accept the notion that working people in the wealthiest nation in
the history of the world should just surrender to the increasing anxiety we
all feel about health care and retirement security.
Their union also plays a strong role fighting for a national health plan for
all Americans, consciously connecting their particular fight to preserve what
is human and sacred in their lives to the same things we all care about and
need: our families, our health, a secure future.
Unlike all too many of us, they join and fight as an independent social force
made up of members who are aware, informed, militant and motivated. They're
doing their job.
Ever hear of the American dream? Well, it just doesn't fall from the sky. As
the old labor song says, "You've got to work for it, fight for it, day
and night for it, and every generation's got to win it again."
Gene Carroll is the director of the Union Leadership Program
at Cornell University, New York State School of Industrial & Labor Relations,
in New York City.