Fifteen persons were arrested Wednesday in front of the White House
after winding their way for two hours through the streets of the nation’s
capital, demanding the U.S. stop torturing detainees in military prisons.
Members of Witness Against Torture began their protest at the steps of the
U.S. Supreme Court, continuing to the Capitol and the Department of Justice,
and ending at the White House where U.S. Park Police carried out the arrests.
Speakers called on officials in each of the buildings to cease planning and
executing policies that have injured and killed people in prisons such as Guantanamo
Bay, Bagram in Afghanistan, and Abu Ghraib in Iraq.
Arrested were Art Laffin, of the Dorothy Day Catholic Worker House in Washington;
Amanda and Matt Dalaisio, and Tania Theriault of the Catholic Worker’s
Mary House in New York; Susan Crane from Jonah House in Baltimore; Matt Vogel,
Mark Colville, Brian Kavanaugh, Carmen Trotta, Jacqueline Allen-Doucot, Alice
Gerard, Bill Streit, Tom Feagley, Edith Tetaz and Jordan Manuel.
The march took place on Ash Wednesday, the first day of Lent, an annual period
when Catholics pray and fast to repent for sins. Speakers included many biblical
references in their remarks.
At the Department of Justice, Bill Streit used passages from the Book of Isaiah
to condemn the DOJ’s role in torturing prisoners. “Your hands are
stained with blood, your fingers with guilt; Your lips speak falsehood, and
your tongue utters deceit . . . Right is repelled and justice stands far off;
for truth stumbles in the public square. Honesty is lacking, and the man who
turns from evil is despoiled.”
Following Streit, Kristine Huskey, an attorney just back from Guantanamo where
she represents a detainee, described torture methods prisoners have reported
to her and other attorneys.
The 38 year-old attorney from the firm of Shearman and Sterling explained that
some 30 detainees had been on a hunger strike since late last summer to protest
their treatment. Despite being roughly force-fed, several others joined the
strike on Christmas Day. At that point, military officials at Guantanamo ordered
even harsher methods.
“Soldiers would strap a prisoner to one of several specially-purchased
metal chairs with six-point restraints, insert an oversized tube through his
nose and purposely overfeed him, causing him to vomit, defecate and urinate
all over himself, and then leave him strapped in the chair for hours like that,”
Describing what happened when the military “got serious about ending
the hunger strike after Christmas, she said, “They stopped using lubricant
to help the tubes go down, and began using tubes with metal tips.”
Despite the tortuous forced feedings, she reported, four prisoners remain on
hunger strike at Guantanamo. Other speakers, citing reports from Amnesty International,
corroborated Huskey’s statements and added that prisoners reported many
instances of injuries, bleeding, and unconsciousness from the torture-feeding
methods, plus numerous physical and mental injuries from torture techniques
such as sensory deprivation, beatings, and burning with lighted cigarettes.
She told the protesters and a small knot of bystanders who stopped to listen,
“One of the most important things you can do is keep this issue alive
and not let the world forget. I was just in Guantanamo and I can tell you that
your actions provide a glimmer of hope to these prisoners -- something they’ve
not had before. They are aware of your actions and express their thanks.”
Escorting six fellow protesters dressed in bright orange jumpsuits, hands tied
and hoods over their heads, the marchers proceeded along busy sidewalks to the
White House, carrying signs that read, “You can deny it’s torture,
but the world knows,” “Torture is killing a person without them
dying,” and “Ban all torture -- no exception for Bush.”
Asked for an opinion of the procession that had just passed her, one woman
replied tersely, “I’m not interested.” A second, referring
to a reporter’s notebook, said, “I don’t do that.” A
block later, a third person claimed, “I didn’t even notice it.”
Several blocks further, an employee of the National Association of Manufacturers,
standing in front of its headquarters, answered, “At first I thought it
was against the death penalty and then I saw what it was about. Torture? Sure,
I disapprove. This war is a lie. It’s a fake that’s costing people’s
lives. It’s terrible what’s going on. I lost two brothers in Vietnam.
I know war is profitable, but it’s wrong.”
Arriving at the White House, the march was greeted by two patrol cars and a
paddy wagon, quickly augmented by another wagon and dozens of uniformed and
plainclothes U.S. Park Police and Secret Service agents.
Tourists stopped to watch and take pictures as the activists drew crosses made
of ashes from the wood stove at Jonah House, on the White House sidewalk. Some
of the tourists entered into conversation with the protesters, most stood quietly.
A 17-year-old student from California, asked what he thought about the event,
said, “Torture is still bad, but it’s sometimes necessary to save
other lives.” A passing youth slowed to inquire, “Are the people
being tortured American citizens?” When answered, “No,” he
replied, “then what’ve we got to do with it?” One young man
was overheard telling a woman he was with, “stick around here, honey,
and your face will wind up in a database.”
Francis Gabby, in Washington from Maryland’s Eastern Shore for his job,
began his comments carefully. “They have every right to be here. I happen
to agree with the majority of what they say. I don’t believe we should
be torturing people.”
Asked to respond to the California student’s assertion that torture is
bad but sometimes necessary, the 57-year old building management worker replied,
“It’s like the death penalty where innocent people have been executed,
and besides, it just doesn’t serve any purpose -- in fact, it’s
doing the opposite. It seems like we’re getting bad information anyway.
I don’t have answers, but I don’t think this is the way.”
Anne Montgomery, 79, a participant in the march, said she had been to Iraq
many times with Voices in the Wilderness and Christian Peacemaker Teams. She
said, “The U.S. is exporting a tremendous escalation of violence; feeding
more violence in the world. Actions like this are important so that people will
know that not all Americans are behind the war. Every action that says we disapprove
of what our government is doing helps.”
Referring to the four CPT members still held hostage in Iraq, Montgomery said
yesterday’s demonstration and others like it may well be helping them
stay alive and contribute to their release.
Finished drawing the ashen crosses, 15 people stood with banners and signs
in the “no protest” zone along one section of the White House fence
and waited to be arrested. In the hour it took the Park Police to begin that
process, several of the soon-to-be-arrested spoke.
Her back to the fence, Theriault stated for all to hear, “Torture and
indefinite detention do not represent us and do not make us secure.”
In a voice fit for a theatrical production, Trotta boomed, “I’m
thinkin’ about lunch counter sit-ins -- deliberate, deliberate breaking
of the law. I’m thinkin’ about Martin Luther King, and the Catonsville
9. I’m even thinkin’ about the Boston Tea Party -- that was deliberate
The police officers arrested each person, methodically tying their hands behind
their back with plastic handcuffs. Three of the arrestees were sitting on the
sidewalk in orange jumpsuits, hooded, with their hands tied in front of them.
Officers removed the hoods and had to unwrap the electrical cord binding their
hands before placing them in handcuffs.
With the arrestees in the wagons, the police drove them to a federal booking
facility in Anacostia, charged them with demonstrating without a permit, cited
them into court at a later date, and released them.
After the action was over, a safety officer wearing a HAZMAT hood and gloves
took samples of the wood ashes on the sidewalk. As people left the area, a motorized
street sweeper cleaned the sidewalk of ash.
Note: Protest organizers said that four days prior to the demonstration
they sent out approximately 1,000 news releases -- 100 to news media outlets
in the D.C. area. Reuters was the only news media outlet seen covering any part
of the actions yesterday.
Mike Ferner is a freelance
writer from Ohio.