Untitled Document
Hidden in the folds of the thickly pork-laden Department of Defense
Appropriations bill that slid through Congress just before Christmas and was
signed into law a day before New Year’s was a big slab of holiday cheer
for the pharmaceutical industry. There were no press releases from congressional
offices and no mention in the news – maybe no one wanted to take credit
for this latest assault on the 14th amendment.
The so-called “Frist provision” – named after the ethically-challenged
physician-turned-politician Bill Frist – will immunize Big Pharma from
responsibility for vaccine-induced injuries. The main rationale for this latest
gift to industry at the expense of the public is -- you guessed it! -- the War
on Terror.
Our representatives in Congress pled that corporations like Merck, GlaxoSmithKline,
Wyeth, and Eli Lilly might just have to close up shop if they were forced to
take responsibility for injuries caused by their products. These companies hardly
need the help. Pharmaceuticals, despite their whining about risk, are some of
the most profitable businesses in the country with the median profit margin
of the top 10 companies more than five times that of all other industries on
the Fortune 500 list.
Vaccine-induced injury has been around for as long as vaccines. The most famous
case is the 1955 “Cutter incident” in which massive scientific,
regulatory and industrial failure led to hundreds of thousands of people being
injected with live polio virus. 70,000 people contacted the disease within days
of being vaccinated, 200 were permanently paralyzed and 10 died.
Two vaccines came into question in the 1990s: measles-mumps-rubella (MMR) and
hepatitis B. According to research reported in 1998 by British physician Andrew
Wakefield and since confirmed by others, the MMR vaccine may cause gastrointestinal
problems that can lead to autism. In 1998, France became the first country to
stop requiring hepatitis B vaccination for school children, following reports
that French children were developing chronic arthritis and symptoms resembling
multiple sclerosis following administration of the vaccine. By 1999, the American
Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) and the Centers for Disease Control (CDC) had suspended
the hep B vaccine for low-risk newborns.
These cases pale in significance compared to the mercury-based vaccine preservative
thimerosal. Lilly introduced thimerosal in the 1930s after testing it on a group
of patients already suffering from meningococcal meningitis. Doctors injected
22 patients with high levels of thimerosal. Most died within days, from meningitis.
Thus, no adverse thimerosal effects were observed.
By the 1990s, American children were routinely receiving vaccinations exposing
them to up to 87 times the EPA safety limit for adult mercury exposure. Government
agencies and the medical establishment argue that there’s no proven connection
between high levels of exposure to the mercury in thimerosal and a sixty-fold
spike in cases of childhood autism. Others disagree.
In metropolitan Chicago, Homefirst Health Services serves several thousand
children whose families have taken advantage of the religious exemption in Illinois
state immunization mandates. According to Dr. Mayer Eisenstein, Homefirst’s
medical director, of the 35,000 children served by Homefirst over the past thirty
years not a single case of autism has been noted among unvaccinated children.
Statistically, there should have been over 200 cases of full-blown autism. Similar
results have been noted among the Amish in Pennsylvania. No vaccinations, no
autism.
American politics is a pay-to-play system. Big Pharma pays big time. Tens of
millions of dollars are given to politicians like Senator Frist each and every
election cycle to insure that corporate interests trump the rights of mere mortals,
including vaccine-injured children and families.
The parents of autistic children, who face costs of $3 to $5 million over their
child’s lifetime, reasonably seek out the courts as recourse. However,
in order for a “vaccine-adverse event” to be compensated in the
federally-established Vaccine Court, it must be listed on the federally-established
Vaccine Injury Table. Autism is not listed.
This is because the Institute of Medicine (IOM) has “failed to find evidence
that thimerosal in vaccines is a causal factor in autism.” The IOM maintains
that while such a link is “plausible,” the evidence is insufficient.
Recently, the CDC tacked in a different direction, with director Julie Gerberding
calling for new studies of the link. But this begs a prickly and potentially
very expensive question: Why have the Centers allowed a huge increase in the
exposure of American children to thimerosal without first guaranteeing its safety?
After all, mercury has long been known to be a neurotoxin and one of the most
dangerous substances on the planet.
With the president signing the Frist provision into law, the pharmaceutical
industry has secured immunity from legal liability for vaccines and drugs administered
to fight “epidemics, pandemics, and bioterror agents.” While the
presumption is that this law will be applied prospectively, in treating an avian
flu outbreak for example, parents of autistic children are justifiably concerned
that it will be applied in a blanket fashion. In other words, total immunity
from allegations of harm related to vaccines: past, present, and future. Injured
persons would be forced to prove “willful intent to harm” –
an extraordinarily high standard – in order to be eligible for compensation.
And – surprise! – the new law provides no funds for compensation.
In the past five years, we have witnessed a steady decrease of our rights alongside
a steady increase of American bullying abroad. One reflects the other. Warrantless
searches. Preemptive war. Detention without charges. Torture. Rendition. Domestic
surveillance. And now, at the instigation of the leader of the Dr. Frist, the
excision of the rights of injured parties to meaningful due process.
We are well down the road of sacrificing our country to a flaccid and
corrupt government in bed with profit-obsessed, amoral corporations. When will
the American people finally say “Enough! We demand our country back!”?
Dan Hamburg is a former member of Congress. He is currently
executive director of Voice
of the Environment, a Marin, CA-based nonprofit.