Untitled Document
Two Reports from the Haiti Information Project
“It was a campaign of fear. Didn’t you hear the radio? They told
people that if they left their homes they would be arrested by the police and
the U.N.,” stated Jean Joseph Jorel, a representative of the National
Commission of the Family Lavalas Cell of Reflection. Jorel made the comment
from Cite Soleil on January 9, the same day the Haitian Chamber of Commerce
had called a national strike to condemn insecurity in Haiti and a recent spate
of kidnappings throughout the capital. Roadblocks manned by the Haitian National
Police and the U.N. went up throughout the capital on January 8 and traffic
remained sparse as most residents stayed in their homes.
Jorel made his comments from Cite Soleil, a bastion of support for ousted president
Aristide and current presidential candidate Rene Garcia Preval. It has served
as a launching site for massive demonstrations demanding the return of Aristide
and most recently as a staging ground for large Preval campaign rallies. Residents
of Cite Soleil accuse Haiti’s business community of pressuring U.N. forces
to commit a massacre there on July 6, 2005.
The January 9 strike came two days after the death of the commander
of U.N. military forces in Haiti Lt. Gen. Urano Bacellar. His death was initially
reported as a suicide but U.N. Special Envoy to Haiti Juan Gabriel Valdes has
implied in recent interviews to the Haitian press that it may have been an assassination
by forces trying to disrupt the electoral process. And finally, the right-wing
opposition of president Mbeki in South Africa with ties to Haiti’s elite
ridiculously implied that a sniper from their country, at the behest of Aristide,
killed the general.
For Jorel and most residents of Cite Soleil, the Chamber’s call to shut
down businesses and transportation is an ominous and frightening portent of
things to come. They do not see the strike as a call for national unity to combat
crime and violence; rather they view it as another attempt by Haiti’s
wealthy elite, and those attempting to forestall upcoming elections, to force
the U.N. to launch military attacks against the neighborhood. They see it as
a repeat of events that led to the massacre of July 6, 2005.
“This is Apaid, Boulos and Baker working to force the U.N. to come in
here and commit another massacre like they did on July 6” declared Jorel
in a familiar refrain heard throughout Cite Soleil. Andy Apaid is a wealthy
sweatshop owner and the leader of an organization that dropped the 0 from Haiti’s
year of independence, 1804, to create a civil society organization named Group
184 that was heavily funded by the United States, France and Canada. The Group
184 helped to build opposition to Aristide’s government and Apaid was
among the first to refer to para-military forces that invaded Haiti from the
Dominican Republic as freedom fighters as they killed police officers and Lavalas
officials in their bid to oust Aristide. Dr. Reginald Boulos is the president
of the Haitian Chamber of Commerce who is implicated in the death of 60 children
after his company, Pharval Pharmaceuticals, produced a poisonous cough syrup
distributed throughout poor neighborhoods of the capital. Boulos had also pushed
the U.N. to make armed incursions into pro-Aristide neighborhoods last May that
many view as having led to the massacre in Cite Soleil on July 6. Charles Henry
Baker, another sweatshop owner, helped to create the Group 184 and is currently
a presidential candidate seen as the preferred choice of Haiti’s wealthy
elite and business community.
“Why do they keep postponing these elections when everyone knows
that Preval is the people’s choice? Why are they afraid of democracy when
they claim that removing Aristide was for democracy? We still believe they kidnapped
our president and forced him out. Now we stand ready to vote again for Preval
and they keep delaying the vote. Is it because they want to rob us of our democratic
rights once again? Is it because so many people are getting rich from the coup
of Feb. 2004 that the international community is so blind they can’t see
the truth?” asked Jorel.
“Don’t go there. There are killers and bad people.”
As the jeep of journalists approached the two Armored Personnel Vehicles (APVs),
manned by Jordanian soldiers and two Haitian police officers, they motioned
for them to stop. Everyone got out of the car to have their identification checked
as the soldiers assured themselves that the lone Haitian driver was not kidnapping
them. The journalists were about to enter the fabled land of poverty and misery
that has been targeted recently as a repository for kidnapping victims in the
Haitian press and mainstream international media. One of the Jordanian soldiers
cautioned, “Be careful. Don’t go there. There are killers and bad
people.”
After being followed by another APV, the Haitian driver finally negotiated
his way to the central marketplace in Cite Soleil on a street named Bwa Neuf.
Bwa Neuf is the site of a monument erected in honor of another supposed Lavalas
“bandit”, Emmanuel “Dread” Wilme. U.N. forces assassinated
Wilme and four of his armed lieutenants on July 6 and residents accuse them
of targeting unarmed civilians during the raid. Dread, as residents of Cite
Soleil refer him to, was an orphan who grew up in La Famni Selavi, the organization
founded by Aristide to help homeless street children. Like so many others, he
saw his parents killed by the military following the coup that ousted Aristide
in 1991. While the US-installed government, the Haitian elite and the U.N. demonized
Dread as a criminal, the impoverished residents of Cite Soleil put their pennies
together and built a monument to his memory.
“They killed my wife and have left me to take care of our nine children.”
Bwa Neuf is patrolled by several APVs 24-hours a day. Residents claim that
at any given hour wherever people congregate to talk about the community or
share ideas with one another, they open fire with automatic weapons. According
to the testimony of residents, four women were killed by U.N. forces in the
marketplace of Bwa Neuf on January 6. Dieunord Edme, 51 years-old, described
how his wife Annette Moleon, 45 years-old, was gunned down by U.N. forces on
that day from a passing APV: “They started shooting everywhere for no
reason. They killed my wife and have left me to take care of our nine children.
Why did they do that?”
The fear was palpable as residents of Haiti’s poorest neighborhood continued
to surround the group of journalists to respond to the news that the U.N. had
announced the results of an investigation into the events of July 6. APVs passed
by several times and residents said the only reason they didn’t open fire
was because of the presence of white foreigners. Yet so many killings by U.N.
forces have gone unreported by the press and human rights organizations. For
example, Zapada Price, a man described as “fou” (crazy) by the community,
ventured too close to the U.N. checkpoint. His body lay on the road for four
days because every time his family came to collect the corpse U.N. forces reportedly
fired at them as well.
“The blue helmuts are lying. They killed so many people and I praise
God that I am alive to call them liars,” shouted 30 year-old Edline Pierre-Louis
who was 6 months pregnant when the U.N. opened fire on July 6. Showing us the
scars on her stomach, she exclaimed, “I lost my unborn baby to U.N. forces
on July 6. If they say there was not a massacre then tell me where is my child?
Where is my brother who bled to death in the street? The U.N. is lying. They
are the ones embarrassing themselves with this lie. Look at how many victims
have come forth to tell you the truth.”
On Jan. 8, residents of Cite Soleil also spoke against a campaign by Haiti’s
wealthy elite to destroy them because of their fidelity to the cause of ousted
president Aristide and their support for the campaign of Rene Preval. “My
brother has been shot and killed by the U.N., my cousin was shot and killed
by the U.N. on July 6. The U.N. is lying. Look at my stomach and the operation
they performed to save my life. The U.N. is lying!” stated Amavil Joudain.
He was shot in the stomach by U.N. forces on July 6, 2005. Other victims of
July 6 who gave testimony to journalists included:
Pierre, Samson, 37, bullet in the stomach; Carole Janvier, 52, bullet to the
chest; Mimose Gabriel, 52, home fired upon, stray bullet to the stomach; Leonise
Cenard, 46, bullet to the stomach.
During the raid of July 6, not a single ambulance or medical unit accompanied
U.N. forces as they opened fire in the community with what was described by
residents as “a hail of bullets.” The U.N. ultimately relied upon
witnesses and testimony presented to them by the Haitian police and human rights
“expert” Jean-Claude Bajeux to dismiss the evidence. Bajeux is a
member of the Group 184 and known for his bias and visceral hatred of Lavalas.
The U.N. to date has never interviewed nor spoken to a single resident of Cite
Soleil. Despite direct testimony by victims of the July 6 U.N. military incursion,
the official report by the MINUSTAH forces concluded: “The targeted victims
were either individuals suspected of having been the informants of MINUSTAH,
or of the people who imprudently expressed their joy at the announcement of
the supposed disappearance of Dread Wilmé and some of his close associates.”
In other words, the U.N. ultimately concluded that the victims were shot and
killed by members of Lavalas in retaliation for informing and expressing “joy”
for their [the U.N.’s] military incursion.
The U.N.’s dismissal of the testimony of victims of July 6 and the recent
pressure applied for another raid in Cite Soleil by virtue of the strike called
by the Haitian Chamber of Commerce on Jan. 9 was foreshadowed by another dark
event on December 30, 2005. The Canadian government, responsible for the reformation
of Haiti’s corrupt judiciary, stood by and watched without comment as
Judge Jean Pérs Paul ordered the release of the following individuals
implicated in kidnapping in Haiti but never mentioned by the Chamber of Commerce
during their strike:
* Stantley Handal; * Wilfrid François, Haitian police officer Agent
1; * Sony Lambert, Haitian police officer Agent 3; * Rénald Cinéus,
Haitian police officer Agent 4.
Handal is a member of one of Haiti’s wealthiest families that supported
the ouster of Aristide in 1991 and 2004. He was initially arrested along with
eight members of Haiti’s police force for running a kidnapping ring after
he attempted to use a stolen credit card taken from one of his victims. The
judge that released them, Jean Pérs Paul, is responsible for keeping
Father Gerard Jean-Juste behind bars and for the arrest of journalists Kevin
Pina and Jean Ristil on September 9, 2005. The police officer responsible for
the initial investigation into Handal’s case has reportedly been forced
into hiding. The U.N. and the Canadian government have not commented on the
case since Jean Pérs Paul ordered the suspects released.
U.N. accused of attacking hospital in Haiti
Friday, January 20, 2006
HIP, Haiti - It was about 11 p.m. at St. Catherine's hospital in Cite Soleil
on Wednesday night as exhausted doctors and nurses were treating numerous victims
of gunshots wounds and filling out paperwork for the four corpses of the unfortunate
ones whose lives they could not save.
"There had been a rush of gunshot victims and those who would talk told
us it was the result of the U.N. opening fire on them. All of a sudden we heard
loud booms and glass breaking and then we realized the hospital was being fired
upon. At first we couldn't tell where it was coming from but then we saw the
tracers coming from the direction of the old Boulos market that is now an armed
encampment for the Jordanians in Cite Soleil. There was panic as a bullet struck
a window in the Children's Ward and everyone went diving for cover," explained
a hospital worker who asked to remain anonymous.
A foreign doctor who also asked their name not be used stated, "We are
not sure where the bullets came from but if what everyone is saying is true
[that the gunfire came from U.N. troops] there can be no excuse or justification
for firing at this hospital."
Jeanette Lager, a 38 year-old mother clutching her ailing 2 month-old son,
described the attack, "My friends who were on the street said they saw
the U.N. firing at the hospital. I was inside with my sick baby when all of
sudden glass started breaking and we could hear the gunfire from across the
road where the U.N. controls the street. Look at the size of the bullet holes,
look at the damage they caused. These were not small weapons. The U.N. is killing
us in the streets and now they are attacking the only hospital we have in Cite
Soleil. It's criminal and it must be stopped."
Benis Benjamin, whose 8 year-old daughter Valancia was shot in their home by
U.N. forces the same night, described his fear as gunfire struck the hospital.
"My little girl was shot in our home by MINUSTAH last night and I had to
rush her here to save her life. The only reason she is alive is because of this
hospital. Then I had to worry she might be a killed a second time when they
began firing on the hospital. Thank God the hospital is still here," Mr.
Benjamin stated.
As the on again, off again elections approach a renewed deadline of Feb. 7,
the United Nations Stabilization Mission in Haiti (MINUSTAH) is being pressured
to crack down hard on poor neighborhoods that are accused of remaining loyal
to ousted President Jean-Bertrand Aristide. Many of these same communities have
also been staging grounds for large campaign rallies in support of presidential
candidate Rene Garcia Preval.
The attack on St. Catherine's comes on the heels of the killing of two Jordanian
soldiers last Tuesday night. Those killings were preceded by a demonstration
in the capital the day before by Haitians that supported the forced ouster of
Aristide on February 29, 2004. Led by members of Haiti's wealthy elite, most
notably Andre Apaid, Dr. Reginald Boulos, and Charles Henry Baker; the demonstrators
criticized the U.N. for being too soft on criminals and not doing enough to
restore security.
Andy Apaid is a wealthy sweatshop owner and the leader of an organization that
dropped the zero from Haiti's year of independence, 1804, to create a so-called
civil society organization named Group 184. The organization was heavily funded
by the United States, France and Canada and helped to build opposition to Aristide's
government. Apaid was among the first to refer to para-military forces that
invaded Haiti from the Dominican Republic as freedom fighters even as they killed
police officers and Lavalas officials in their bid to oust Aristide.
Dr. Reginald Boulos is the president of the Haitian Chamber of Commerce who
is implicated in the deaths of at least 60 children after his company, Pharval
Pharmaceuticals, produced a poisonous cough syrup distributed throughout poor
neighborhoods of the capital. Boulos had also pushed the U.N. to make armed
incursions into pro-Aristide neighborhoods last May. Survivors and members of
the community charge this led to a massacre committed by U.N. forces in Cite
Soleil on July 6, 2005. Charles Henry Baker, another sweatshop owner, helped
to create the Group 184 and is currently a presidential candidate seen as the
preferred choice of Haiti's wealthy elite and business community.
Jordanian forces in Cite Soleil attempted to block the access of journalists
into another area of the community where more reported killings of unarmed civilians
occurred yesterday. After finding another route around the Jordanians, journalists
saw evidence of at least two more persons residents said were gunned down by
MINUSTAH forces Thursday morning. John Erickson's body lay less than 30 feet
from a wide street named Bwa Neuf that is patrolled by Jordanian soldiers in
Armored Personnel Vehicles 24-hours a day. Residents claimed he was shot along
with several others at about 9 a.m. when gunfire erupted from U.N. forces.
Another man, known by his neighbors only as "Ti Blan", lies in a
pool of blood and was the apparent victim of a single shot that ripped into
his chest. All of those interviewed at the scene repeated several times that
the victims were unarmed at the time U.N. forces opened fire.
Journalists leaving Cite Soleil and traveling through the neighboring community
of Pele witnessed first-hand new tactics being employed by Brazilian forces
to pacify the area.
A man described by residents as being a member of a group called the GNB, hid
his identity behind a mask made of camouflaged cloth as he led Brazilian soldiers
through the area in search of what he described as "bandits." He stopped
and questioned a woman using a cellular telephone on the street and then took
the phone away from her and began searching through the directory for numbers.
He called a number with no apparent luck, returned the phone and told her that
if he saw her again he would have her arrested.
When questioned by a reporter the masked man stated he was a private citizen
who had "volunteered to help the Brazilians rid Haiti of bandits"
and said he was not being paid for the service. When asked if he was otherwise
gainfully employed he retorted, "This is my job. I am going to find the
bandits for these guys and they have given me my authority. I don't need money
to eat."
After the masked man led the Brazilians down a side street and out of earshot,
residents began to complain that he was one of at least eight individuals being
used by U.N. forces in the area as paid informants. One woman who spoke out
afterwards said, "Those masked guys have been responsible for arresting
a lot of innocent people over the past three weeks. They are using this as a
form of political and personal revenge and the U.N. doesn't seem to care if
innocent people are killed as a result or if they end up in jail. This situation
is like living in a nightmare."
For article with photo essay visit: http://haitiaction.net/News/HIP/1_20_6/1_20_6.html
The Haiti Information Project (HIP) is a non-profit alternative news
service providing coverage and analysis of breaking developments in Haiti.
For more information: To view 7-minute trailer of "Haiti: The
UNtold Story" visit: www.teledyol.net
for further infomation about the Haiti Information Project (HIP) visit:
http://www.teledyol.net/HIP/about.html
Contact: HIP@teledyol.net