Untitled Document
In 2002, syndicated columnist Maggie Gallagher repeatedly defended President
Bush's push for a $300 million initiative encouraging marriage as a way of strengthening
families.
"The Bush marriage initiative would emphasize the importance of marriage
to poor couples" and "educate teens on the value of delaying childbearing
until marriage," she wrote in National Review Online, for example, adding
that this could "carry big payoffs down the road for taxpayers and children."
But Gallagher failed to mention that she had a $21,500 contract with the Department
of Health and Human Services to help promote the president's proposal. Her work
under the contract, which ran from January through October 2002, included drafting
a magazine article for the HHS official overseeing the initiative, writing brochures
for the program and conducting a briefing for department officials.
"Did I violate journalistic ethics by not disclosing it?" Gallagher
said yesterday. "I don't know. You tell me." She said she would have
"been happy to tell anyone who called me" about the contract but that
"frankly, it never occurred to me" to disclose it.
Later in the day, Gallagher filed a column in which she said that "I should
have disclosed a government contract when I later wrote about the Bush marriage
initiative. I would have, if I had remembered it. My apologies to my readers."
In the interview, Gallagher said her situation was "not really anything
near" the recent controversy involving conservative commentator Armstrong
Williams. Earlier this month Williams apologized for not disclosing a $241,000
contract with the Education Department, awarded through the Ketchum public relations
firm, to promote Bush's No Child Left Behind law through advertising on his
cable TV and syndicated radio shows and other efforts.
Gallagher received an additional $20,000 from the Bush administration in 2002
and 2003 for writing a report, titled "Can Government Strengthen Marriage?",
for a private organization called the National Fatherhood Initiative. That report,
published last year, was funded by a Justice Department grant, said NFI spokesman
Vincent DiCaro. Gallagher said she was "aware vaguely" that her work
was federally funded.
In columns, television appearances and interviews with such newspapers as The
Washington Post, Gallagher last year defended Bush's proposal for a constitutional
amendment barring same-sex marriage.
Wade Horn, HHS assistant secretary for children and families, said his division
hired Gallagher as "a well-known national expert," along with other
specialists in the field, to help devise the president's healthy marriage initiative.
"It's not unusual in the federal government to do that," he said.
The essay Gallagher drafted appeared under Horn's byline -- with the headline
"Closing the Marriage Gap" -- and ran in Crisis magazine, which promotes
humanism rooted in Catholic Church teachings. Horn said most of the brochures
written by Gallagher -- such as "The Top Ten Reasons Marriage Matters"
-- were not used as the program evolved.
"I don't see any comparison between what has been alleged with Armstrong
Williams and what we did with Maggie Gallagher," said Horn, who founded
the National Fatherhood Initiative before entering government. "We didn't
pay her to write columns. We didn't pay her to promote the president's healthy
marriage initiative at all. What we wanted to do was use her expertise."
The Education Department is now investigating the Williams contract.
The author of three books on marriage, Gallagher is president of the Washington-based
Institute for Marriage and Public Policy, a frequent television guest and has
written on the subject for such publications as the New York Times, Wall Street
Journal and Weekly Standard.
While she was being paid by HHS in 2002, Gallagher in her syndicated column
dismissed the arguments against "President Bush's modest marriage initiative"
as "nonsense," writing: "Bush plans to use a tiny fraction of
surplus welfare dollars to fund marriage education services for at-risk couples."
In a column later that year that appeared in the Myrtle Beach (S.C.) Sun News,
Gallagher said Bush's welfare-revision bill would, among other things, encourage
"stable marriages," and that it was a "scandal" for Democrats
to reject the president's plan and fail to offer an alternative.
National Review Editor Rich Lowry said of the HHS contract: "We would
have preferred that she told us, and we would have disclosed it in her bio."
Tribune Media Services dropped Williams's column after his administration contract
was disclosed. Universal Press Syndicate, which distributes Gallagher's column,
plans no such action.
"We did not know about the contract," spokeswoman Kathie Kerr said.
"We would have probably liked to have known." But, Kerr said, "this
is what we hired Maggie to write about. It probably wouldn't have changed our
mind to distribute it."