Untitled Document
For the last week the US government has been reeling both from the revelation
that it employed white phosphorous in Fallujah and from the discovery that the
government it helped install is running secret detention centres in which prisoners
are subjected to serious abuse.
The detention facility in the Jadiriyah district of Baghdad was discovered
on Sunday 13 November when US soldiers entered an Interior Ministry building
in their hunt for a missing 15-year-old. What they discovered was a chamber
of horrors. More than 170 prisoners were packed into a foetid underground bunker.
They were half-starved and many of them had been seriously beaten. Torture instruments
were found hidden above a false ceiling and reports stated that some prisoners
had been flayed.
Predictably, the US embassy issued a statement denouncing the treatment and
insisting that torture was unacceptable, while Iraqi prime minister Ibrahim
Jafaari insisted there would be an enquiry and Hussein Kamal, deputy head of
the Interior Ministry, downplayed the incident. Such denials failed to convince
the intrepid western media, which cannily pointed to Shia domination of the
government, especially the Interior Ministry. A number of reports also cited
rumours that the facility had been used by the Badr Brigade, the former armed
wing of The Supreme Council for Islamic Revolution in Iraq. For the majority
of western journalists, the incident is yet another example of what they claim
is a wave of sectarian violence sweeping Iraq.
What the western media has so far failed to disclose is that a strikingly
similar incident occurred just a day after the nominal handover of power to
Ayad Allawi’s Interim Government. On 29 June 2004, military police from
the Oregon National Guard stormed the compound of the Interior Ministry itself
to rescue dozens of detainees whom they had observed being tortured. As at Jadiriyah,
the victims had been deprived of food and savagely beaten. Dozens more detainees
were discovered in sheds, alongside instruments of torture. Some of the detainees
were in a life-threatening condition and the guardsmen began to administer emergency
medical care.
Most shockingly, when the guardsmen radioed for support, senior US
officers ordered them to stand down. After hours of tense negotiations, the
guardsmen reluctantly withdrew, leaving the prisoners with their abusers.
The incident demonstrates two extremely important points. Firstly, the latest
discovery is not news for US authorities, who have been aware of serious abuse
taking place inside Interior Ministry facilities for more than a year and taken
no action to prevent it. Secondly, such abuse cannot simply be ascribed to sectarian
Shia control of the Interior Ministry. In fact, many of the most senior posts
at the Ministry continue to be filled by ex-Baathists, including some of those
most associated with suppression of the Shia rising that followed the first
Gulf War.
The practice of torture at Interior Ministry facilities is in many ways the
tip of the iceberg. For the last year hundreds of bodies - the apparent victims
of extrajudicial executions - have been turning up across Iraq, especially Baghdad.
Typically, the victims are bound and blindfolded and have been dispatched with
shots to the head and chest. Many of them also bear the marks of brutal torture.
The only serious investigation to have been carried out within Iraq was by
an Iraqi journalist, Yasser Salihee. He pointed to the hundreds of execution
victims making their way through the Baghdad morgue and highlighted the fact
that in many cases those victims are known to have been arrested by gunmen in
police uniforms, sporting expensive police equipment, including vehicles, weapons
and sophisticated radios. His final article was published on 27 June, three
days after his own assassination at the hands of a US sniper, but his allegations
echo those of Sunni groups, who have accused the government of state terrorism.
The majority of specific accusations have focused on a unit called the Wolf
Brigade, attached to the Interior Ministry’s Special Police Commandos.
This unit, formed in autumn last year, saw its first major action in Mosul in
November 2004 in what seems to have been a serious clash with resistance fighters.
Dozens of bodies began to appear on the streets as the commandos conducted sweeps
of the city.
More recently, in July, the Wolf Brigade is known to have been responsible
for an incident in which 11 bricklayers were seized at a Baghdad hospital and
locked in the back of a police vehicle in searing heat for 16 hours. Ten of
the men died and doctors carrying out a post mortem concluded that the victims
had also been subjected to torture, including by electrocution.
Whilst death-squad-style killings are now generally acknowledged, the perpetrators
are almost always claimed to belong to Shiite militias, perhaps under the control
of a Shiite-dominated Interior Ministry. Even the Wolf Brigade is linked with
sectarian violence, but the reality is that the Special Police Commandos are
composed of ex special-forces and Republican Guard personnel and were established
by former Baathists with long histories of involvement with the CIA, under the
supervision of US counterinsurgency experts. One advisor was the same James
Steele who previously commanded the US military mission in El Salvador at the
height of that country’s unspeakably dirty civil war. There, Steele was
responsible for creating the ‘elite’ squads that accounted for the
bulk of the army’s largely civilian casualties.
Another was Steven Casteel, the most senior US advisor within the Interior
Ministry and the man who successfully negotiated the withdrawal of the Oregon
National Guardsmen. Some of his experience was gained in Colombia, where he
was involved in the Centra Spike operations, a data-collection exercise in which
lists of the associates of cocaine baron Pablo Escobar were murdered by the
Los Pepes death squads. Los Pepes went on to form the nucleus for the present
murderous AUC.
The US, largely through the CIA, has a long history of involvement
with genocidal intelligence operations, from Indonesia under Suharto, through
Operation Phoenix in Vietnam, to present-day Colombia. The current mass arrests
in Iraq and subsequent killings bear all the hallmarks of such an operation.
By analogy, one can reasonably guess that the current flood of victims will
include anyone opposing US hegemony, such as the hundreds of teachers and academics
who have already been assassinated, as well as the human ‘waste’
generated through ‘heavy interrogation’. A further possibility is
that ordinary Sunni Iraqis are deliberately being victimised as part of a strategy
of fomenting sectarian strife designed to engineer the Balkanisation of Iraq.
With that in mind, it is time to start asking hard questions about the role
of the two British SAS men caught with a car load of explosives and accused
by Iraqis of planning to attack a Shia religious festival.
According to The Guardian, one former Interior Ministry detainee claimed
prisoners prayed to be transferred to Abu Ghraib. This is no commendation of
US treatment of prisoners, but only highlights the fact that many of the worst
crimes are reserved, as they have been in Latin America, for US proxies. In
El Salvador Noam Chomsky noted that it was not enough for US-backed paramilitaries
to kill someone; instead they might be decapitated and their head placed on
a spike. In Iraq similar distinctions exist. The victims of US-trained death
squads are not just humiliated; their eyes are gouged out, their skin is peeled
off and electric drills are driven through their knees.