Federal scientists say they will consider requests to ship the recently
recreated 1918 killer flu virus to select U.S. research labs.
There are 300 non-government research labs registered to work with deadly germs
like the Spanish flu, which killed millions of people worldwide. The Centers
for Disease Control and Prevention will consider requests for samples from those
labs "on a case-by-case basis," CDC spokesman Von Roebuck said Wednesday.
Dangerous biological agents are routinely shipped through commercial carriers
like FedEx or DHL, following government packaging, safety and security guidelines.
Last month, U.S. scientists announced they had created — from scratch
— the 1918 virus. It was the first time an infectious agent behind a historic
global epidemic had ever been reconstructed.
Researchers said they believed it would help them develop defenses against
the threat of a future pandemic evolving from bird flu, which was found to have
similar characteristics as the 1918 virus.
About 10 vials of virus were created, each containing about 10 million
infectious virus particles. CDC officials said at the time the particles would
be stored at a CDC facility in Atlanta, and that there were no plans to send
samples off campus.
But that statement did not mean there was a policy against sending samples
elsewhere, Roebuck said.
The agency's decision to consider shipping the virus outside Atlanta was first
reported in the latest issue of the journal Nature. Some critics of the recreation
of the virus were not pleased to learn of plans to ship the germ.
"Obviously, that contradicts what most people were led to believe when
the results of the 1918 experiments were published," said Edward Hammond,
director of the Sunshine Project, an Austin, Texas-based organization that advocates
more control of biological weapons and biotechnology.
In addition to creating the virus, the scientists said they would place the
gene-sequencing information from the new research in GenBank, a public database
operated by the National Institutes of Health.
GenBank will allow some research groups to build their own virus, rather than
seek samples of what the CDC had created.
"But that would be a lot of work. Wasted, duplicative work, if they (the
CDC) have already made it," said Dr. Diane Griffin, chair of molecular
microbiology and immunology at Johns Hopkins University's Bloomberg School of
It's impractical to expect every influenza researcher who could learn from
the 1918 virus to travel to Atlanta, said Michael Osterholm of the University
of Minnesota School of Public Health.
"There's very limited lab space there," said Osterholm, director
of Minnesota's Center for Infectious Disease Research & Policy.
The CDC currently has no pending requests for the virus, Roebuck said. It's
unlikely many requests would come in right away, Osterholm noted.
The government requires researchers who work with such agents to use highly
secure labs that meet strict training and equipment requirements. About 300
labs are registered for handling such agents, and all are located in the United
States, Roebuck said.
"This (virus) is not going to go willy nilly to anyone who wants it,"