Untitled Document
James Yee entered Guantanamo as a patriotic US officer and Muslim chaplain.
He ended up in shackles, branded a spy. This is his disturbing story
My cell was 8ft by 6ft, the same size as the detainees’ cages at Guantanamo.
Barely a week ago I had received a glowing evaluation for my work as the US army’s
Muslim chaplain among the “Gitmo” prisoners. Now I was the one in
chains.
It was my turn to be humiliated every time I was taken to have a shower. Naked,
I had to run my hands through my hair to show that I was not concealing a weapon
in it. Then mouth open, tongue up, down, nothing inside. Right arm up, nothing
in my armpit. Left arm up. Lift the right testicle, nothing hidden. Lift the
left. Turn around, bend over, spread your buttocks, knowing a camera was displaying
my naked image as male and female guards watched.
It didn’t matter that I was an army captain, a graduate of West Point,
the elite US military academy. It didn’t matter that my religious beliefs
prohibited me from being fully naked in front of strangers. It didn’t
matter that I hadn’t been charged with a crime. It didn’t matter
that my wife and daughter had no idea where I was. And it certainly didn’t
matter that I was a loyal American citizen and, above all, innocent.
I was accused of mutiny and sedition, aiding the enemy and espionage, all of
which carried the death penalty. I was regarded as a traitor to the army and
my country. This was all blatantly untrue — as would be proved when, after
a long fight, all the charges against me were dropped and I won an honourable
discharge from the army.
I knew why I had been arrested: it was because I am a Muslim. I was just the
latest victim of the hostility born the moment when the planes flew into the
twin towers and the Pentagon on September 11, 2001.
My real “crime” had been that I had tried to ensure that the suspected
Taliban and Al-Qaeda fighters detained in the Gitmo cages were given every opportunity
to practise their religion freely, one of the most fundamental of American ideals.
I had monitored the atrocious treatment meted out by the guards. And I had
come to suspect that my appointment as the prisoners’ chaplain was simply
a piece of political theatre.
When reporters came to Guantanamo on the media tour, everyone had always wanted
to talk to the Muslim chaplain. I had told them the things that the command
expected me to say. We give the detainees a Koran. We announce the prayer five
times a day. We serve halal food. Everything I said had been true. But it certainly
wasn’t the full story.
I HAVE NOT always been a Muslim. I am a third-generation American — my
grandparents left China in the 1920s — and as a child in New Jersey I
grudgingly attended Lutheran church services with my mother.
On holiday after graduating from West Point, however, I met a young woman who
was intrigued by Islam. I began to read about it and eventually converted. Then,
after the US army sent me to Saudi Arabia and allowed me to visit Mecca, I wondered
why there were no Muslim chaplains in the US military.
My father had taught me as a boy that America promises all people an opportunity
to lead an extraordinary life. By becoming a Muslim chaplain in the summer of
2000, after four years’ study in Damascus, I saw myself fulfilling this
opportunity. I had no idea what I was letting myself in for.
Six months after the September 11 attacks I was asked if I would like to work
at Camp X-Ray, the new detention centre at Guantanamo Bay. I said that it would
be difficult: Huda, my Syrian wife, was still adjusting to life in America and
Sarah, our daughter, was in the throes of the “terrible twos”. It
turned out, however, that I had no choice.
By the time I got to Guantanamo, Camp X-Ray was too small for the number of
prisoners coming in. When I saw its remains I couldn’t believe that humans
were once held here. It looked like a cattle yard. There were hundreds of cages
in rows. The only protection from the blistering sun was a tin roof. Dozens
of enormous rodents crawled throughout the camp. I was told that these were
banana rats and would attack if provoked.
The new prison, Camp Delta, consisted of 19 blocks, each holding 48 detainees
in individual open-air cells with steel mesh walls. Like other military personnel,
I was briefed that the detainees were among the most dangerous terrorists in
the world. We were told that many of the prisoners were responsible for the
attacks of September 11 and would strike again if given the opportunity.
I expected to come face-to-face with hundreds of Osama Bin Ladens, but most
prisoners were friendly. There were approximately 660 from dozens of countries,
including Britain.
An English-speaking Saudi detainee named Shaker was eating a military “Meal
Ready to Eat” or MRE when I first met him. MREs often led to constipation.
“Chaplain,” Shaker called out. “You know what we call this
lunch we eat every day? Meals that Refuse to Exit.”
Shaker said that he had settled in London after marrying a British woman. They
had three children and his wife had given birth to his fourth child after he
was captured. “My youngest son, we named him Faris, I’ve never seen,”
he told me. “My wife doesn’t know anything about what happened to
me and I’m so worried about her.”
I got to know three men from Britain particularly well: Rhuhel Ahmed, Asif
Iqbal and Shafiq Rasul. Ahmed, the most talkative, told me that they had grown
up together in Tipton, near Birmingham. Their families were close and the men were
like cousins. All three told me they had never committed a crime and that their
arrests had been a serious mistake.
The man in overall charge was Major General Geoffrey Miller, a slight but self-confident
Texan in his late fifties. He was later sent to Iraq to make recommendations
on improving intelligence collection at Abu Ghraib prison in the months before
it became infamous for the maltreatment of its inmates.
If there was trouble with the prisoners, guards were supposed to restore order
calmly. But Miller said when visiting Camp Delta or whenever seeing troopers
around the base: “The fight is on!” This was a subtle way of saying
that rules were relaxed and infractions were easily overlooked.
Miller was a devout Christian. In one of the first private conversations that
he and I had, he invited me for a stroll under the watchtowers and told me that
several of his friends and colleagues had been killed in the 9/11 attack on
the Pentagon.
He had felt a deep anger towards “those Muslims” who attacked the
World Trade Center and the Pentagon — such anger, he explained, that he
had sought counselling with a chaplain. I appreciated his candour but I sensed
there was a subtle warning behind his words.
THE WORST punishment for prisoners was a “forced cell extraction”
by a group of six to eight guards called the Initial Response Force. The troopers
called it IRFing.
I witnessed my first IRFing after a military policeman had performed the “credit
card swipe” — pressing his fingers inside a detainee’s buttock
crack to look for a weapon. This type of physical contact is not acceptable
under Islamic law and the detainee had pushed the guard away. But prisoners
were not allowed to touch an MP and immediately eight guards were summoned.
They put on riot protection gear — helmets, heavy gloves, shin guards
and chest protectors — before forming a huddle and chanting in unison,
getting themselves pumped up. Still chanting, they rushed the block, their heavy
boots sounding like a stampede on the steel floor. Detainees throughout Camp
Delta started to yell and shake their cage doors.
When the IRF team reached the offending detainee, the team leader drenched
him with pepper spray and opened the door to his cell. The others charged in.
He was no match for eight men in riot gear. The guards used their shields and
bodies to force him to the floor. With his wrists and ankles tied, he was dragged
down the corridor to solitary confinement.
When it was over the guards high-fived each other and slammed their chests
together like professional basketball players — an odd victory celebration
for eight men who took down one prisoner.
IRFing was used with extraordinary frequency. Seemingly harmless behaviour
could bring it on: not responding when a guard spoke or having two plastic cups
in a cage instead of the regulation one. Invasive body searches occurred daily
and were a constant source of tension leading to IRFing. I came to believe that
the searches were done solely to rile the detainees. The prisoners had been
locked in cages for several months in a remote area of Cuba. What could they
possibly be hiding?
Violent episodes were increasing. In one incident a guard had to be hauled
off a handcuffed detainee whom he was beating on the head with a handheld radio.
By the time I arrived the detainee had been taken to the hospital, but his blood
was fresh on the ground and what appeared to be large pieces of flesh were soaking
in it.
Bad as this violence was, many soldiers discovered a weapon far more powerful
than fists: Islam. Because religion was the most important issue for nearly
all the prisoners in Camp Delta, it became the most important weapon used against
them.
Guards mocked the call to prayer and rattled doors, threw stones against the
cages and played loud rock’n’roll music as the prisoners prayed.
Knowing that physical contact between unrelated men and women is not allowed
under Islamic law, female guards would be exceptionally inappropriate in how
they patted down the prisoners or touched them on the way to the showers or
recreation. Detainees often resisted and were IRFed.
The guards knew that Muslims believe that the Koran contains the actual words
of God and is to be treated with the utmost respect. I never heard of an incident
where a detainee hid anything dangerous in the Koran; doing so would be considered
an insult. Yet the guards shook the prisoners’ Korans violently, broke
bindings, ripped pages and dropped the book on the floor, all on the pretext of searching them.
Some of the worst complaints that I received were about what was happening
inside the interrogation rooms. Some of the translators — Muslim military
personnel like me — told stories about female interrogators who would
take off their clothes during the sessions. One would pretend to masturbate
in front of detainees. She was also known to touch them in a sexual way and
make them rub her breasts and genitalia. A translator who had witnessed this
woman’s behaviour told me that her supervisor had told her to tone down
the tactics but had not disciplined her.
Translators with the Joint Intelligence Group (JIG) also confirmed that some
prisoners were forced to prostrate themselves in the centre of a satanic circle
lit with candles. Interrogators shouted at them, “Satan is your God, not
Allah! Repeat that after me!”
I came to believe that the hostile environment and animosity towards Islam
were so ingrained in the operation that Miller and the other camp leaders had
lost sight of the moral harm we were doing.
I began to keep a record of the atrocities that I was hearing about. But the
more time I spent on the blocks the more aggressive many of the guards became
towards me. I was authorised to have unescorted access and to speak with detainees
in privacy. But guards eavesdropped on my conversations, standing very close
and attempting to intimidate me. Most refused to move away.
“I’ve been told to stay within one arm’s length of you at
all times,” one guard told me.
When an administrative assistant in the navy chaplain’s office showed
me a slanderous and hatefilled diatribe against Muslims that was to be inserted
into a weekly newsletter to hundreds of Christian military personnel on the
base, I decided it was time for action.
It began, “Egyptian Muslim Mohammad Farouk hated Christians . . . in
an attempt to obey the Koran and please Allah, Mohammad and his friends began
to assault and harass Christians in their village . . .” It claimed that
the Koran instructs Muslims to espouse violence and hatred, the opposite of
the truth.
Yet Vincent Salamoni, a Catholic priest who worked as the naval command chaplain,
only grudgingly complied with the advice from the Christian chief chaplain on
the base not to distribute this material. Salamoni said that he felt it was
necessary first to find out if the Koran did instruct Muslims to kill Christians.
In briefings to newcomers to the base, given with the express support of the
operations staff, I tried to dispel the principal myth that all Muslims are
terrorists. Little did I understand that by trying to educate my colleagues
about the need for religious tolerance, I was encouraging them to suspect me.
Although I had been ordered to prepare the presentation by the command, the
fact that I talked knowledgeably about Islam was enough to lead some of them
to question my loyalty.
Captain Jason Orlich, an army reservist who had taught in a Catholic school
before arriving in Guantanamo to take charge of intelligence and security for
detention operations, sat in my briefing on his first day and asked: “Is
he on our side or is he on the enemy’s side?” As I was to discover
much later from court documents, he made it his mission to keep an eye on me. Nor
was I the only one under suspicion: Muslim colleagues — all loyal Americans
— were spied on and bugged.
When I got together with other Muslim personnel on the base, our conversation
routinely turned to what appeared to be open religious hostility.
Ahmad al-Halabi, a young airman who helped me with the detainees’ library
of religious books, told me that he had been given a copy of a CD widely circulated
by the troopers. Among the images on it was a phoney Playboy cover showing Muslim
women in provocative dress and poses, and another depicting Muslim men engaged
in anal sex during prayer. He suspected that the disc had originated in the
security section headed by Orlich, who appeared in several photographs on the
disc.
All of us on the base knew that, like the detainees, we were likely to be under
surveillance wherever we were. Watch what you’re saying, soldiers would
joke, because the “secret squirrels” are listening. We never knew
exactly who they were, but the government agencies represented on the island
included the FBI, Naval Criminal Investigative Service, Army Counterintelligence
and the CIA. Nothing was off limits. Our e-mails were read, our telephone calls
were monitored and everything we said had the potential of being overheard.
I had a feeling that our Muslim Friday prayers, attended by about 40 in a small
room at the chapel complex of the camp, were under surveillance. Men in khakis
and polo shirts — the common uniform of the FBI and CIA — would
stand just outside, watching to see who came and went. I sometimes asked if
they wanted to join us but they always declined, offering no explanation of
their presence. A translator confirmed that a man sitting outside was an FBI
agent he had worked with in interrogations.
WHEN I was given a larger apartment to live in, I called some of the guys to
come over and share evening prayers in my spare bedroom. Afterwards we hung
around in my living room and had sodas and snacks. Before long, evening prayers
at my house became a frequent occasion and word spread among the Muslim personnel
that anyone who wanted to join us was welcome. People started turning up with
tasty Middle Eastern food. I did not realise what the repercussions would be.
Many months later I learnt the facts from court documents.
People initially became suspicious of me because of the presentation that I
gave during the newcomers’ briefing. Stories quietly began to circulate
about me and my fellow Muslim personnel. We were too sympathetic to the plight
of the detainees and too critical of how the MPs treated the prisoners. We prayed
together on Friday afternoons. Orlich even noted that Ahmad was seen to be “shadow
boxing” as he left the chapel. “I found that to be odd,” Orlich told a military investigator.
The accusations were retold and exaggerated in back yards and on the beaches
during the hot Cuban evenings, fuelled by boredom and discount vodka. Some troopers
adopted names for us: “the Muslim clique” and, far more disturbing, Hamas, after the Palestinian
organisation.
Did these soldiers truly believe the things they were saying about us and were
they truly threatened by the fact that we practised our religion? Or were they
just caught up in the pervasive anti-Muslim hostility that defined the mission?
I believe that those who accused us of being “radical Islamists”
were unable to see that someone can be a Muslim and not be a terrorist.
Most of the Christian soldiers at Guantanamo practised their religion regularly
and attended weekly services. Miller was rarely missing from the front row of
the chief chaplain’s service, which gave it an unstated command emphasis.
Three Christian chaplains hosted weekly Bible studies where soldiers met to
discuss their faith. I am sure that they believed this made them better people
and better soldiers and helped to ease the tremendous strain of life at Guantanamo.
Why couldn’t they see that we were simply doing the same?
For months Orlich watched me and the other Muslims who regularly attended my
religious services. He was particularly concerned with Ahmad whose “case”
was assigned to Lance Wega, a young civilian agent from the Air Force Office of Special Investigations.
Investigators twice surreptitiously entered Ahmad’s living quarters.
They took photographs of the house, copied his telephone records and mirrored
the hard drive on his computer.
Microsoft was instructed to store Ahmad’s e-mails and records of his
internet activity without his knowledge.
“You are requested to not disclose the existence of this request to the
subscriber or any other person,” the letter to Microsoft stated. “Any
such disclosure could subject you to criminal liability for obstruction of justice.”
Many Muslim personnel came to me to share concerns that things just didn’t
feel right. Staff Sergeant Mohammad Tabassum, a no-nonsense type of guy in his
mid-forties, told me that he had been cleaning out a cupboard in his house on
the base and discovered a listening device hidden inside.
Ahmad then told me that his security clearance had been suspended. He was the
last person I thought would come under suspicion; he was a loyal American and
an exceptional soldier, the best translator in the camp.
When Ahmad’s tour of duty came to an end, he left with great excitement,
heading for Syria to be married. He and his fiancée had been forced to
postpone the wedding when his deployment at Guantanamo was extended. His mother,
who had recently recovered from cancer, was to meet Ahmad at the airport in
London and then fly with him to Damascus.
A few days after Ahmad left, however, we heard that he had been arrested in
Jacksonville, Florida, when he got off the plane from Guantanamo. Nobody knew
why or what had happened to him.
After a few weeks news arrived that Tariq Hashim, an air force captain who
had been on the same plane, had also been arrested. The FBI had taken both of
them. Then we had heard that another member of our prayer group, Petty Officer
Samir Hejab, a navy cook, had been arrested as he left Guantanamo at the end
of his deployment.
Suddenly it seemed as if every Muslim at Guantanamo was being detained on reaching
American soil. Were we all going to be arrested and jailed without explanation?
In the midst of this confusion, I decided that it was time for me to take a
break from Guantanamo. Every trooper was allowed a short vacation and by late
August I was ready for mine. I felt overjoyed at the idea of seeing my family
again. But I also was growing more concerned by the day that something suspicious
was happening behind the scenes.
“Have you heard anything about Muslim personnel being arrested recently?”
I asked Orlich.
He looked me in the eye. “Nothing,” he told me.
“The situation is strange,” I said to him. “There’s
a lot of rumours and I’m wondering if I’m next.”
Orlich smiled and put his hand on my shoulder, “Now why would anyone
want to arrest you, chaplain?”
I persisted: “Because I am the Muslim chaplain and the one who leads
these three missing Muslims in prayer.”
Orlich just laughed off my concerns.
My wife said she had my gun in one hand and two rounds in the other
I still don’t understand how the misguided suspicions of a few inexperienced
soldiers led to the ordeal that changed my life, tore apart my family and destroyed
my career.
While my plane headed home to the US on September 10, 2003, representatives
of at least five government agencies awaited me at the Jacksonville air station:
FBI, Naval Criminal Investigative Service, US Bureau of Immigration and Customs
Enforcement, US Customs and Border Protection and Army Counterintelligence.
After my arrest I was sure that General Miller would order my release. He ran
a tight ship and he was a tough leader, but he was a general and he would therefore
be fair. But when I was at last arraigned at a pre-trial hearing, I was presented
with a memorandum signed by Miller that stated: “Chaplain Yee is known
to have associated with known terrorist sympathisers.”
He added: “Yee is suspected of several extremely serious crimes, including
espionage, which potentially carries the death penalty.”
I was too cut off from the world to know that the news of my arrest had broken
and that the government was slandering me in the press. There were reports that
I had contact with Syrian government officials, that I was affiliated with Al-Qaeda
and the Taliban, and that I had been found with maps of Guantanamo and names
of the detainees and interrogators.
Sometimes I wondered if I would go crazy trying to deal with the situation
and being locked in solitary confinement for what turned out to be 76 days.
If it were not for my military training and my religion, perhaps I would have.
After a month I learnt that I was not going to be charged with spying, sedition
or aiding the enemy after all but with the “slap on the wrist” charges
of taking classified information to my housing quarters and of transporting
classified material without the proper container. But my hopes quickly vanished
when my lawyer told me that the army was saying that more serious charges might
still be brought.
I discovered that I was in the same prison as Yasser Hamdi, an American-born
Saudi who was allegedly captured fighting US forces in Afghanistan, and Jose
Padilla, who was arrested in Chicago on suspicion of belonging to Al-Qaeda and
participating in a plot to detonate a dirty bomb in the United States. Both
were deemed enemy combatants. Did this mean I was, too?
At another pre-trial hearing, investigators claimed I was part of a spy ring.
The press repeated false information from anonymous government sources that
it was one of the most dangerous spy rings to be discovered in the US military
since the cold war.
The army was doing far more harm to me privately. Martha Brewer, an agent with
the Department of Defence Criminal Investigative Service, went to my apartment
near Seattle and told Huda, my wife: “Your husband is not the person you
think he is. He’s having an affair with three women.”
She produced photographs of me with female colleagues on social occasions at
Guantanamo in what was clearly a desperate attempt to turn Huda against me.
Although these photographs would have been acceptable to most people, Brewer
clearly understood that given her traditions, Huda would be particularly upset
to see me photographed with women. Huda later told me she was so distressed
that some days she couldn’t get out of bed and all she could do was cry.
On November 25, with no serious charges in sight, I was suddenly released from
custody. But the same day news bulletins announced that I was being charged
with adultery (a criminal offence in the military) and with downloading pornography
on a government computer. By revealing the new charges on the day of my release
from prison, the army had captured the story.
I called Huda and had one of the most difficult experiences of my entire ordeal.
She told me that when she had learnt of the new accusations, she had searched
out my Smith & Wesson .38 special handgun, which I kept on the top shelf
in my cupboard, hidden from view.
“I’m holding it in one hand,” she told me, “and two
rounds in the other.”
“Put it down,” I said firmly, fear rising inside of me.
“Tell me how to use it,” she whispered. She said that she couldn’t
deal with this any longer and wanted to be free from everything — the
media, the scrutiny, the idea that the United States government could be doing
this to our family. It was not the first time that Huda had suggested a desire
to die since my arrest, but it had never gone this far.
I didn’t know what to do. She hung up and when I called back several
times, she didn’t answer. Finally I called the local police department.
They sent officers to our apartment, who took Huda to a nearby hospital against
her will. She was released after several hours, but the police kept the gun.
I could not be with her. I was forbidden to leave my military base.
In February last year my lawyers reached a deal with the army that the criminal
charges would be dismissed and I would resign my commission with a recommendation
for an honourable discharge from Miller and other senior officers. Even so,
the military continued to whisper that I was indeed a threat to the nation but
it was somehow in the interest of security to drop the case against me. Miller
found me guilty of adultery and possessing pornography and formally reprimanded
me. Two months later — by which time my case had become a cause celebre
— I won an appeal against his decision.
After the charges against me were dropped and it became obvious that the government
had erred, many newspaper editorials were written to demand that the military
issue an apology.
Of course I want an apology, but it will not restore my marriage which has
suffered irreparable damage from the vindictive claims that the military made.
Nor will it give me back my job as a Muslim chaplain in the army — a job
that allowed me to fulfil my dream of serving both God and country.