Untitled Document
|
David M. Satterfield, deputy
chief of the United States mission in Baghdad, is accused of giving classified
information to a pro-Israel lobbyist |
The second-highest diplomat at the United States Embassy in Baghdad is one of
the anonymous government officials cited in an Aug. 4 indictment as having provided
classified information to an employee of a pro-Israel lobbying group, people who
have been officially briefed on the case said Wednesday.
The diplomat, David M. Satterfield, was identified in the indictment as a United
States government official, "USGO-2," the people briefed on the matter
said. In early 2002, USGO-2 discussed secret national security matters in two
meetings with Steven J. Rosen, who has since been dismissed as a top lobbyist
for the American Israel Public Affairs Committee, known as Aipac, who has been
charged in the case.
The indictment said that Mr. Rosen met USGO-2 on Jan. 18, 2002, and March 12,
2002, but provides few details about the encounters. The indictment does not
describe Mr. Satterfield's activities in detail nor does it specify what classified
information the diplomat discussed with the lobbyist. The meetings were also
confirmed by documents, people who have been briefed said. These people asked
not to be identified because many of the matters related to the case are classified.
The indictment does not accuse USGO-2 of any wrongdoing, nor does it indicate
whether he might have been authorized to talk with the lobbyist. Mr. Satterfield
is not believed to be the subject of a continuing investigation. He is the first
higher-ranking government official to be caught up in the criminal inquiry.
Mr. Satterfield's role in the inquiry has been known within a small circle
at the State Department. Before he was sent to Baghdad, officials at the State
Department asked the Justice Department whether the investigation posed any
impediment to his assignment in Iraq, someone who has been officially briefed
said. Officials at the State Department were advised that he could take the
job.
Mr. Satterfield is one of the department's rising stars. Before his assignment
as deputy chief of mission in Baghdad, Mr. Satterfield, 50, held several jobs
in the Clinton and Bush administrations as a Middle East expert. He was ambassador
to Lebanon from 1998 to 2001, and was confirmed by the Senate as ambassador
to Jordan in 2004, although he never served in that position.
Current and former colleagues say that Mr. Satterfield, who went to Iraq earlier
this year, chose the Baghdad post because it posed a bigger professional challenge
than Jordan. The United States ambassador to Iraq, Zalmay Khalilzad, has strong
political credentials but, colleagues said, Mr. Satterfield was brought in to
provide managerial strength.
Mr. Satterfield did not respond to an e-mail message asking about his role
in the case, and one State Department spokesman said that Mr. Satterfield would
not discuss the matter. Sean McCormack, the spokesman for the department, referred
legal questions about Mr. Satterfield to the Justice Department.
He added, "David is a fine public servant who has served the American
people for many years and is continuing to do so under difficult working conditions."
The investigation is one of the more puzzling national security cases in recent
years, focusing on the interactions between foreign affairs lobbyists and officials
of the United States and other governments, who over the years, have routinely
traded gossip and sometimes classified information. Under the Justice Department's
theories of the case, it is no longer clear whether such conversations are legally
permissible.
Current and former colleagues praised Mr. Satterfield as a seasoned and careful
diplomat. "I've known David Satterfield for 20 years, and he is thoroughly
professional, and takes his responsibilities very seriously," said Dennis
Ross, the former chief Middle East negotiator for the United States and a longtime
State Department official. "He has always acted solely in American interests."
Martin Indyk, Mr. Satterfield's former boss in the Clinton administration, both
at the National Security Council at the White House and at the State Department,
said the idea that Mr. Satterfield leaked classified information is "absurd."
"The way he speaks is crafted for a public audience," Mr. Indyk said.
"He has this facility for talking publicly without saying anything sensitive.
So the idea that he would be leaking classified information is preposterous.
"He has an unblemished record as the consummate diplomat and as a highly
effective policy maker as well. He is among the cadre of the best and the brightest
in the Near East Bureau. He dealt with Aipac, because it was part of his job
to deal with Aipac."
Mr. Rosen and another former lobbyist, Keith Weissman, have been charged with
conspiring to communicate national defense secrets to journalists and a foreign
government, which officials have identified as Israel. A third person, Lawrence
A. Franklin, a former Pentagon analyst and Iran expert, has also been charged,
accused of turning over information to the two lobbyists.
At an arraignment on Tuesday in Federal District Court in Alexandria, Va.,
all three pleaded not guilty and were released on their own recognizance. Judge
T. S. Ellis III set a trial date for Jan. 3.
Only Mr. Rosen met with USGO-2, according to the indictment. At the time of
the meetings, Mr. Satterfield was the deputy assistant secretary for Near Eastern
and South Asian affairs, which made him the State Department's second-ranking
official for the Middle East.
Their meetings are listed as overt acts in a conspiracy to illegally communicate
national defense secrets to a foreign government. After Mr. Rosen's first meeting
with USGO-2 on Jan. 18, 2002, the indictment said, a memorandum containing the
information that Mr. Rosen had obtained was sent to other Aipac employees. The
indictment did not indicate who wrote the memorandum, but said that it "contained
classified information provided by USGO-2."
The two men met again on March 12, the indictment said. At their second meeting,
they talked about Al Qaeda, the indictment said, without saying what aspect
of the terror network was discussed. On March 14, Mr. Rosen disclosed to an
unidentified foreign official, "FO-2," the information that he had
heard from USGO-2, the indictment said.
Prosecutors have charged that Mr. Rosen and Mr. Weissman improperly obtained
classified information from Mr. Franklin, Mr. Satterfield and two other American
officials. The two officials whose identities remain unclear are referred to
in the indictment as "USGO-1," and a Defense Department employee identified
as "DOD-B." Although USGO-1 has not been publicly identified, the
people who have been officially briefed said that person was no longer in the
government.
As the Aipac's director of foreign policy issues, Mr. Rosen was a well-known
figure in foreign policy circles related to the Middle East, inside and outside
the government. He helped Aipac set its lobbying goals and maintained relationships
with powerful conservatives in the Bush administration. Mr. Weissman was a senior
Middle East analyst.
Several Middle East experts noted that Mr. Satterfield was never regarded as
particularly supportive of Aipac's views on Israel. One analyst at an independent
consulting firm recalled attending a conference Aipac held for Congressional
staff members, during which Mr. Satterfield talked about United States policy
toward Israel. She recalled that Mr. Satterfield was met with a mixed reception
because his comments were not in line with Aipac's views.