Untitled Document
Solidarity officially fell apart at the AFL-CIO Monday as the service employees
and Teamsters unions -- two of the biggest in the federation -- pulled out of
the national labor body, an expected move that could hit the bottom line of labor
organizations here.
The decision to disaffiliate was not a happy one, said Service Employees International
Union President Andrew Stern, following the kickoff of the AFL-CIO convention
here. Differences over strategies to rebuild the labor movement made it necessary,
he said.
Union members, who once made up roughly one of every three private sector workers,
account for just 8 percent of the private sector today, he said, highlighting
his view of the need for change.
Workers "have less health care, less time to spend with their families,
less secure pensions in their retirement, but more debt and more insecurity
about the future," Stern said.
"... Our world has changed. Our economy has changed. Employers have changed."
But the AFL-CIO is not willing to make fundamental change as well, he said.
SEIU was the biggest union in the AFL-CIO with 1.8 million members. The International
Brotherhood of Teamsters has 1.4 million members. The departures will mean a
roughly $20 million annual hit to the AFL-CIO's budget.
"We will spend our money differently," said Teamsters President James
P. Hoffa. "We will mobilize our work force differently. What was being
done at the AFL-CIO is not working. We're going to do something new. It's going
to work."
The unions plan to focus on building the dissident Change to Win Coalition,
which they founded last month with the United Food and Commercial Workers union,
the Laborers' International Union and UNITE-HERE -- a union of grocery, retail,
hotel, restaurant and textile workers. The coalition has since attracted the
carpenters and farm workers unions.
UNITE-HERE and the food and commercial workers union are also weighing whether
to pull out of the AFL-CIO and joined SEIU and the Teamsters in boycotting this
week's convention.
The four account for roughly $30 million of the AFL-CIO's $125 million annual
budget and nearly 40 percent of affiliate unions' 13 million members.
Excluding the laborers, the dissidents' union members account for 147,200 of
the roughly 460,000 workers in AFL-CIO unions affiliated with the Chicago Federation
of Labor and roughly 38 percent, or $1.2 million, of the local federation's
budget. That's according to Dennis Gannon, CFL president.
SEIU accounts for about 7 percent of the Illinois AFL-CIO's roughly $2 million
annual budget, and the Teamsters account for roughly 3 percent, said Illinois
AFL-CIO President Margaret Blackshere.
The dissident unions plan to continue working with central labor councils and
state AFL-CIOs, including providing funding, union officials said. But that
might not be possible.
The national AFL-CIO's constitution prohibits affiliates from working with
disaffiliated unions. But Burger and Blackshere noted the rules haven't always
been enforced.
"I don't know what's going to happen," Blackshere said. "I don't
know whether we'll have a loss of revenue. It's sad and disappointing. I wish
they would just keep trying to resolve their differences."
Gannon said that despite the national split, he's optimistic Chicago labor
will be united.
The coalition has been pushing for major changes at the AFL-CIO, including
increased funding for organizing, financial incentives to encourage more union
mergers and new rules to prevent one union from undercutting the contract standards
won by other unions.
AFL-CIO President John Sweeney, who was first elected 10 years ago after having
served as president of SEIU, blasted the departures.
"It is a tragedy for working people," he told delegates at the convention.
"Because at a time when our corporate and conservative adversaries have
created the most powerful anti-worker political machine in the history of our
country, a divided movement hurts the hopes of working families for a better
life."
He said he plans to work to bring the groups back together.
The departure comes at a time when the AFL-CIO, in the face of pressure from
the dissidents has announced major reforms that will be voted on this week,
including increased funding for organizing and proposals to give the federation
the power to develop and enforce contract standards.
Hoffa and Stern said the reforms fall short and signalled no interest in reunification.
"We wish the AFL-CIO well, and hope they are successful," Stern said.
"We may disagree but we have no intention to be disagreeable. But working
people in American can't afford to wait any longer."
Democrats rally for AFL-CIO at convention
BY SCOTT FORNEK POLITICAL
REPORTER
One after another, the Democratic stars took to the podium Monday to pay homage
to the AFL-CIO and thank the labor giant for the political muscle it regularly
flexes on the party's behalf.
"I didn't watch this presidential campaign on television," said former
vice presidential nominee John Edwards. "I was there. And I know what happened.
"Without the men and women of organized labor, there was no presidential
campaign."
The former North Carolina senator made no mention of the split that is now
dividing the labor organization. And neither did most of the other national
Democrats who addressed the AFL-CIO's annual convention at Navy Pier -- including
House Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi, NAACP Chairman Julian Bond and U.S. Sen.
Barack Obama.
Union leaders weren't so reticent. Most conceded the decision of the Teamsters
and the Service Employees International Union was a damaging blow, but all sought
to downplay the political fallout.
"Listen, it is clearly better for us to stay together," Harold Schaitberger,
president of the International Association of Firefighters, told reporters.
"I don't believe it's going to diminish labor's political power because
I would suggest that regardless of the ultimate outcome ... I'm committed and
convinced that we will still remain in lockstep on our political and legislative
agendas.
Tom Buffenbarger, president of the International Association of Machinists
and Aerospace Workers, said the departing unions weren't much help.
"I really don't think it hurts labor's political clout, because the unions
that have left have a mixed bag on who they supported and how much they support
and what kind of effort they bring to the process," he said. "The
unions that still make up the AFL-CIO today have a long history, well documented
and demonstrated that they are the core unions for labor's political clout."
In the 2004 elections, the AFL-CIO spent $40 million mobilizing its forces,
mailed out 30 million political fliers, put 5,000 staffers and more than 225,000
volunteers in the field, according to union officials. And nobody was predicting
that power would suddenly go to the Republicans.
"Based on the really right-wing Evangelical conservative record that the
Republicans now have and will hold, I can't see any union being really difficult
to deal with in terms of unifying behind a particular candidate," said
Gerald McEntee, president of the American Federation of State, County and Municipal
Employees, with 1.3 million members, now the AFL-CIO's largest member union.
McEntee said the split might be felt more in races for governor or other contests
further down the ballot.
The politicians were approaching the problem more cautiously.
U.S. Sen. Edward M. Kennedy (D-Mass.) was one of the few to talk openly about
the division, telling the crowd it is "trying times for labor."
"We all know that families have their differences," Kennedy said.
"We all know that disagreements can sometimes be painful. But always remember
the ancient proverb: 'Me against my brother, but my brother and me against the
world.'
"Together, we will take on that world, because what divides us pales in
comparison with what unites us."
Kennedy went out of his way to heap praise on the AFL-CIO and its president,
John Sweeney, who is under fire from the unions that broke away, calling him
"my kind of president."
The Massachusetts Democrat also pledged to continue to fight for labor, predicting
"we will emerge from these times bigger and stronger than before."
Edwards told the crowd that labor will remain "the heart and soul"
of the Democratic Party.
"We're going to let the Republicans stand ... with their friends on Wall
Street, big insurance companies, big drug companies, big HMOs, Haliburton,"
Edwards said. "I'll tell you who we're going to fight for.
"We're going to fight for the men, women that you represent every single
day."