INTERNATIONAL AFFAIRS - LOOKING GLASS NEWS | |
Border talks called `disturbing' |
|
by Sean Gordon Toronto Star Entered into the database on Saturday, February 19th, 2005 @ 01:31:09 MST |
|
OTTAWA—An influential tri-national panel has considered a raft of bold
proposals for an integrated North America, including a continental customs union,
single passport and contiguous security perimeter. According to a confidential internal summary from the first of three meetings
of the Task Force on the Future of North America, discussions also broached
the possibility of lifting trade exemptions on cultural goods and Canadian water
exports. Those last two suggestions were dismissed in subsequent deliberations, say
members of the task force, an advisory group of academics, trade experts, former
politicians and diplomats from Canada, the United States and Mexico sponsored
by the New York-based Council on Foreign Relations. Members said the task force's final report this spring will focus on "achievable"
rather than simply academic questions like that of a single North American currency. Nevertheless, the initial debates prompted a sharp reaction from trade skeptics
and nationalist groups like the Council of Canadians, who fear business leaders
and the politically connected are concocting plans to cede important areas of
sovereignty at the behest of American business interests. Council of Canadians chairperson Maude Barlow said the summary, a copy of which
was obtained by the Toronto Star, was "disturbing" and "shocking." "What they envisage is a new North American reality with one passport,
one immigration and refugee policy, one security regime, one foreign policy,
one common set of environmental, health and safety standards ... a brand name
that will be sold to school kids, all based on the interests and the needs of
the U.S.," she said. She said the discussions have added weight because the panel includes such
political heavyweights as former federal finance minister John Manley. Thomas d'Aquino, head of the Canadian Council of Chief Executives and one of
the task force's vice-chairs, said the summary reflected only preliminary discussions
and scoffed at Barlow's concerns, saying insinuations of a secret agenda are
"totally wrong." "There is an acute awareness that we have three independent countries
who have no intention of compromising their sovereignty," he said, adding
the discussions on water and culture particularly "had no legs whatsoever." Federal officials stressed the panel is independent of government policy, and
that while efforts will continue to work with the United States to address common
security and trade concerns, there are no discussions regarding more formal
continental integration. D'Aquino brushed aside the concerns stemming from the summary document, saying
"every member of the task force is an independent, the first meeting was
basically a scattering of ideas ... a great deal of ground has been covered
since then." And where Barlow and others see a sinister plot to serve the interests of corporate
America, d'Aquino sees an effort to co-operate in the face of emerging economic
powerhouses in Asia. The document talks about the need to develop a North American brand, and muses
about the possibility of common immigration and customs policies, closer consultation
on monetary policy and integrated security policies. Points of discussion included: "Trilateralizing customs and immigration at airports, ports and land
borders." "Applying the principle of inspection, one test, one certification throughout
North America" for agriculture. "Treating all North American citizens as domestic investors in each country." |